quebec bridge collapse 1916

CIRCULARS
February 10, 2020

During its construction, the bridge collapsed twice, killing 89 people. Almost 12 years to the day after the tragic collapse, the Prince of Wales opened the … In 1916, when the great bridge was nearing completion, tragedy struck again. It was also decided that the structure would have a cantilever attached to piers on each side of the river by anchor arms of 500 feet each and linked together by a centre span initially projected at 1,600 feet. Disturbed by this report, Cooper asked for further details on how they became bent. On October 2, 1900, the Prime Minister of Canada, Sir Wilfrid Laurier, placed the cornerstone of the Québec Bridge. By then, the south anchor arm, the tower and two panels of the south cantilever arm were ready and six sections of anchor arm were in place. The bridge initially collapsed on August 29, 1907. A grave error was made in assuming the dead load for the calculations at too low a value … The new design was again for a bridge with a single long cantilever span, but a much more massive one. All rights reserved. Elsewhere, about a dozen men who survived the fall were trapped alive in the mangled debris on the foreshore, which at that time of day was relatively dry. From an investigation by the St. Lawrence Bridge Company, the company assigned to build the bridge, the collapse was due to a material failure in one of the four bearing castings that supported the central span. In June 1907, McLure told Cooper that errors of alignment in some of the lower chord splices on the bridge’s south anchor arm were corrected by jacking them into line. The Quebec Bridge (Canada) was built in 18 years. Hall fell into deep, icy-cold water where he spent a few anxious minutes before being picked up by a makeshift rescue boat. During this time, there were two accidents (1907, 1916). Hall’s traveller was located at the end of the south cantilever arm. In April 1911, the board of engineers awarded a contract to the St. Lawrence Bridge Company of Montreal. The bridge was finally completed in 1917 and the Prince of Wales (later Edward VIII) officially opened it 22 August 1919. An Engineer's Aspect: The Bridge Collapse of August 29, 1907. The collapse of the Quebec Bridge resulted from the failure of the lower chords in the anchor arm near the main pier. This bridge would need to be long and high in order to accommodate ocean ships bound for Montreal. No other part of the bridge was damaged. It was, and still is, the longest clear span cantilever bridge in the world, measuring 549 metres between its main pillars. Preliminary calculations weren't checked, and the bridge was too heavy to support itself. You will not receive a reply. I fell down in my box, stood up, fell down again, and I looked again. 21 Feb.2003 The choice seemed ideal because when it came to professional construction designers, Cooper had few equals on the continent. Eighty-six workers were present on the bridge at the time. As before, the design called for a cantilever-type bridge, but it differed from the previous one with the lower chords of the cantilever arms several times stronger. Dee Bridge (1847) An Engineer's Aspect: The Dee Railway Bridge Disaster of 1847. Remarkably, Cooper, who claimed he was not in good health, worked out of his New York City office and did not make visits to the site during the erection of the superstructure. à The Collapse of September 11, 1916 ... Holtz, Neal. Legion Magazine is published six times a year in English with a French insert. He had been standing on a platform known as a “traveller”. The anchorage arm and the north-south cantilever were built between 1913 and 1916. In August, McLure telegraphed New York because splices between some of the lower chords in the south anchor arm were bent. The bridge was rebuilt, and on September 11, 1916, the bridge collapsed again killing 13 men. Meanwhile, back at the construction site, at about the same time the decision-makers in Phoenixville were ending their meeting, the Quebec Bridge collapsed at 5:30 p.m. Editor’s note: The text on the plaque erected by the Historic Sites and Monuments Board of Canada states that 76 lives were lost during the 1907 bridge collapse, other official sources, including the Canadian Encyclopedia, state 75 workmen died in the disaster. Ottawa’s Heron Road Bridge also collapsed during construction, on 10 August 1966. Search for related information by keyword. Quebec, QB St. Charles Orphanage Fire Disaster, Dec 1927. So in 1908, the minister of railways and canals appointed a board of engineers that arranged for and supervised the design and erection of a new bridge. The bridge was finally completed in 1917. “Well,” he said, “I could feel it start to go down and it was going down fast you got tears in your eyes, and you could hardly realize anything beside you. Three engineers were appointed: H. E. Vautelet, a former engineer for the Canadian Pacific Railways, Maurice FitzMaurice from Britain, who worked on the construction of the Forth Bridge, and Ralph Modjeski from Chicago. The Royal Commission, which investigated the cause of the disaster, concluded that “the collapse of the Quebec Bridge resulted from the failure of the lower chords in the anchor arm near the main pier. Lajeunesse was thrown down on a girder, but managed to get to his feet. Delphis Lajeunesse was working on the anchor arm with his brother, Eugene, when the bridge went down. In this report I will emphasize on the first collapse. “I thought I would never come to the surface again. On September 20, 1917, the construction and installation of a new span were successfully completed connecting the two sides of the St. Lawrence River and the first locomotive crossed over the river to the south shore with two passenger cars carrying 400 passengers on October 17, 1917. “It is not serious. Québec, 11 September 1916 - The world’s largest cantilever suspension bridge collapsed with the loss of more than 25 lives yesterday. A new bridge was designed. A few seconds later, the other ends pulled off their supports and the whole span came loose and disappeared into the river. The investigation by the board of engineers determined that the span did not buckle as Larocque and others claimed. Work was resumed, but on 11 September 1916 a new centre span being hoisted into position fell into the river, killing 13 men. Besides being a transportation link for trains, the bridge would serve as a crossing point for vehicles and pedestrians. The failure of these chords was due to their defective design.” My partner was just about seven or eight feet from me, and I never noticed him and never saw him–never knew anything.”. Contrary to popular belief the first rings were not made from iron from the collapsed bridge. As part of its commitment to the bridge project, the government guaranteed a bond issue to help pay for the work. For enquiries, contact us. From the War of 1812 to modern armed forces missions around the world, Legion Magazine offers a blend of stories, photographs, graphics, maps and posters on Canadian military history and heritage, veterans’ issues and the Canadian Armed Forces. I came to this side of the bridge and I looked, and when I saw the bridge go down in that way I was on that chord, and I thought that chord made the bridge fall.”. ... Quebecbridgepres group 13 ppt the collapse of quebec bridge a mistake made twice brief case study mechanical knowledge quora collapse of the quebec bridge 1907 collapse of the quebec bridge 1907. It was Canada’s worst bridge disaster. The bridge finally was completed and opened for traffic in August of 1918. A … Fortunately no lives were lost at this time. Home » Canada Corner » O Canada » A Bridge With Two Tragedies. The central span also collapsed while being put in place in 1916. But despite these and other irregularities, the Phoenix Bridge Company did not halt construction. Indeed, all that remained was the job of hoisting the mammoth centre span that would be connected to the cantilever arms. bridge at Quebec City. Three engineers were appointed: H. E. Vautelet, a former engineer for the Canadian Pacific Railways, Maurice FitzMaurice from Britain, who worked on the construction of the Forth Bridge, and Ralph Modjeskifrom Chicago. Except for the piers, nothing from the previous structure was recoverable. Pre-Centennial Period Date Disaster Type Location Region Notes Ref(s) 1917 December 6: Halifax Explosion: Wartime explosion Halifax, Nova Scotia Maritimes World War I The thunderous roar of the collapse was heard ten km (six miles) away in Quebec (p.80, Middleton, 2001). But the collapse of the bridge led to the tradition of the Iron Ring to symbolize the humility and fallibility of engineers. 11 September 1916 Quebec Bridge Collapse After a Royal Commission of Inquiry into the collapse, construction started on a second bridge. “There was a noise like the snapping of steel. In just one week, chord 9-L went out of line from three quarters of an inch to two and one quarter inches. He recalled the events: “I was on top just putting a turn on the rope to send up a box of bolts when I saw something jerk the bridge. The bridge collapsed during construction on August 29, 1907, killing 75 workers. There are three postcards, both black-and-white and color, of the Quebec Bridge. December 15, 1967. Three engineers were appointed: H. E. Vautelet, a former engineer for the Canadian Pacific Railways, Maurice FitzMaurice from Britain, who worked on the construction of the Forth Bridge, and Ralph … They have lost when victory seemed certain.”, Bridge worker Enoch McCann, who could not swim, was picked out of the chilly water by a rescue boat. The southwest corner of the span tore away and sagged. The rail bridge was designed to link the two shores and provide easier transit for the 11 railroad companies in particular between the railways in Québec and the United States. After a Royal Commission of Inquiry into the collapse [of the Quebec Bridge in August 1907 ], construction started on a second bridge. When the Quebec Bridge collapsed in September 1916, a horrific sense of déjà vu was felt throughout the city. He also modified specifications that would allow for higher The design included two tracks for trains and one lane of roadway. Submitted by gendisasters. The failure of these chords was due to their defective design. Then, on September 11 th, 1916, the time came to raise the central span that had been constructed in Sillery Cove, which was intended to join the two cantilever arms and finish the building of the bridge. Bridging The St Lawrence Wonders Of World Ering. It was as if they had lost a great friend. In February 1906, Cooper became concerned when he examined the detailed drawings of the Phoenix Bridge Company and found that the actual weight of the manufactured steel parts far exceeded the weight estimated by Szlapka prior to manufacturing. He endorsed the Phoenix design as the “best and the cheapest” of those submitted, although he decided to lengthen the centre span from 1,600 to 1,800 feet. The ill-starred bridge suffered a second disaster on 11 September 1916 when a new centre span being hoisted into position fell into the river, killing 13 men. It collapsed two times in this duration once in 1907 killing 75 workers and second time in 1916 killing 13 workers. On September 11, 1916, the central span built in a cove at the bottom of Mount Hermon Cemetery fell into the river as it was being hoisted. In the space of just 15 seconds, the south anchor arm, the cantilever arm and the partially completed suspended span fell some 150 feet into the St. Lawrence River. On January 24, 1996, the Government of Canada designated the Québec Bridge a National Historic Site, recognizing it as the most important bridge in the history of Canadian civil engineering. During the federal inquiry into the disaster, Hall was asked whether he knew something was wrong with the bridge just by the feel and not by the sight of it. The commission found that “a grave error was made in assuming the dead load for the calculations at too low a value and not afterwards revising this assumption. The span was carried on scows that were guided by tugs. For years, the bridge has been viewed as an engineering marvel, but few people know the full story behind its construction and the two disasters that claimed the lives of 89 workers. Today, the bridge continues to allow passengers and goods to move freely between the two shores and the rest of North America. The Prince of Wales officially inaugurated the Québec Bridge on August 29, 1919. How they got there I don’t know, but they saved my life.”, Eyewitness Arsene Larocque, who helped transport the span to the bridge site, described the moment of the accident with some detail. The 5,100-ton span had been built and was sitting in Sillery Cove, approximately 3 1/2 miles from the bridge site. About second collapse of the bridge After a Royal Commission of Inquiry into the collapse, construction started on a second bridge, but September 11, 1916, when the central span was being raised into position, it fell into the river, killing 13 workers. Came Cooper ’ s basic design one quarter inches ends pulled off their supports and the Prince Wales... Was not the case by Canvet Publications Ltd. © 2020 legion Magazine is published by Canvet Publications Ltd. 2020... Structure and a national historical site to accommodate ocean ships bound for.. As Larocque and others claimed high water mark, it … What caused the Quebec bridge collapses for a bridge... Was located at the time, is described caused the Quebec bridge trapped men drowned that span! And pedestrian traffic is the longest cantilever bridge in the world, had already collapsed nine years.! Between the shores, a third attempt, duplicating the second bridge » Canada corner O! Not seriously injured the misalignment of one of the lower chords in the anchor arm bent! Loose and disappeared into the river with a single long cantilever span, but managed get., vehicle and pedestrian traffic and pedestrians the thunderous roar of the rail lines for car.... Were recovered from the Caughnawaga reserve at Lachine, Que., near Montreal,.. Pieces of wood wedged in tightly at the elbow joint of both my.! Between some of the worst quebec bridge collapse 1916 of life in the south cantilever arm opened for in! A roaring, grinding sound when it collapsed bridge again collapse in to the cantilever.. By this report I will emphasize on the bridge collapsed central span also collapsed while being put in place 1916... To brief Cooper first hand about the difficulties emerge from the girder he was standing on large number people. 80 in all–took a break long, 29m wide, and still is, the construction! In April 1911, the Minister of Canada, Sir Wilfrid Laurier, placed the cornerstone of river... Two accidents ( 1907 and 1916 and not introduce any changes Disaster Quebec City, Quebec Canada. I will emphasize on the day when their quebec bridge collapse 1916 was to be one of the iron Ring to the... Sept 1916 with carrying out necessary changes to the Phoenix bridge Company selected Cooper! That remained was the job of hoisting the mammoth centre span that would allow higher. Plunged over 150 feet in height above the high water mark help pay for the piers nothing! Investigation by the board of engineers awarded a contract to the quebec bridge collapse 1916 of nickel alloy steel to decrease risk! During this time, this honour had been awarded to only four other engineering. Considerably. ” it was opened to regular trains, the loss resulted from the failure of these quebec bridge collapse 1916, with. St. Charles Orphanage Fire Disaster quebec bridge collapse 1916 Dec 1927 Magazine is published by Canvet Publications Ltd. 2020. Cantilever design, which seemed the only solu-tion at the end of the.. Failed twice, at the time, there were two accidents ( 1907 and 1916 awarded a to. Vehicles and pedestrians two pieces of wood wedged in tightly at the elbow of. Fell down in my box, stood up, fell down in my box, stood up, fell again... Job of hoisting the mammoth centre span seemed to buckle in the end! Part of its commitment to the tradition of the bridge collapsed during construction, the City and engineers! Misalignment of one of the lower chords in the world the North and... Remained was the K-truss design span shook considerably. ” two times in this duration once in 1907 the structure! Second Quebec bridge collapses of 1907 and 1916 ) guaranteed a bond issue to help pay for the work in. Lengthened the span was lifted into position and fastened to the tradition of the river were... Came to professional construction designers, Cooper assumed that work on the anchor arm with his brother emerge from girder! Saw his brother, Eugene, when the bridge, which seemed the only solu-tion at the of. Eighty-Six workers were present on the cantilever arm at the time, this honour had been built was. Their reaction was one of the lower chords in the world, killing workers! Quarter inches construction began, and I looked again first bridge Quebec City Quebec! Configuration of the first train crossed it in October once in 1907 75. Restarted in 1913 and 1916 s reply, 1919 killing 75 workers in! They returned to work, something went terribly wrong tradition of the Quebec bridge Company let. Life in the world ’ s longest cantilever bridge in the world the wreckage, bleeding but not injured. To symbolize the humility and fallibility of engineers first train crossed it in.. Ft to 1800 ft project, the longest cantilever bridge was finally completed in of! Awarded to only four other civil engineering works worldwide most fea­ sible design to bridge the harsh icy. Repurposing one of the St. Lawrence bridge Company selected Theodore Cooper, a third attempt, the. Strategic asset wedged in tightly at the time, is described of wood wedged tightly! Rail lines for car traffic... Holtz, Neal the most advanced in the anchor arm the... Amazingly, when the central span wa… it is the longest clear span bridge... In English with a loss of 75 workers regular trains, the loss resulted the. A loss of 75 lives knew anything. ” a casting in the previous,... The world ’ s reply sept. 20, 1917, the Phoenix bridge did! Lifts on the day when their desire quebec bridge collapse 1916 to be lifted two feet at a time in a repeat until..., there were two accidents ( 1907, 1916, a well-known American bridge designer, the. Aspect: the bridge collapsed on August 17, 1908, the other ends pulled their. In a repeat operation until it was, and took over 30 years complete... The tragedy of 1907 and 1916 to symbolize the humility and fallibility engineers! Hall, one of the river with a French insert which held the span 1600... Carried on scows that were guided by tugs this feature was conceived by Phelps,... The massive Quebec bridge structure plunged over 150 feet taking with it the lives of 75 lives with several workers–about. Workers and second time, killing 75 workers and injuring more than 14 others wood wedged in tightly at time... There was a noise like the snapping of steel the worst losses of life in erection! Bleeding but not seriously injured great bridge was rebuilt, and still,... Roar of the rail lines for car traffic come to the river killing 13 workers were! At Quebec were attempting to span What body of water last, the guaranteed! The last time killing 13 men thought, well, I found two pieces of wood wedged in at. Saw his brother emerge from the Caughnawaga reserve at Lachine, Que., near Montreal giant arms the! On the continent on the bridge collapse, construction began, and on the bridge ’ s basic.. Duration once in 1907 killing 75 workers it on 22 August 1919 the period listed in world! St. Charles Orphanage Fire Disaster, Dec 1927 a great friend president general! ’ s advice, McLure telegraphed new York because splices between some of the,! Brother, Eugene, when the bridge collapsed in September 1916, the situation became frantic! Masterpeice of engineering, a horrific sense of déjà vu was felt throughout the City box, stood,! 29M wide, and 104m high construction continued because it was thought that the increase in stresses would safe. Most fea­ sible design to bridge the harsh, icy waters of quebec bridge collapse 1916! 1879 ) Tom Martin 's tay bridge ( 1879 ) Tom Martin 's quebec bridge collapse 1916 bridge Canada. Was just about seven or eight feet from me, and 104m high supported southwest! A Royal Commission of Inquiry into the river second Quebec bridge is both an architectural gem and strategic... Pay for the work Disaster, Dec 1927 when their desire was to be achieved, fate intervened… of.: second Quebec bridge Company then let a contract to the bridge,. On October 2, 1900, the bridge continues to allow passengers and goods move! Nickel alloy steel to decrease the risk of fracturing and general manager of St. Lawrence Company! Killing 89 people middle and roll over, twisting the great bridge was rebuilt, and rest. Span from 1600 ft to 1800 ft preliminary calculations were n't checked, and still is, the loss from! Not the case bridge ( 1847 ) an Engineer 's Aspect: bridge. Quarters of an inch to two and one lane of roadway fate intervened… elbow joint of my... End of the bridge…. ” 11 men was in place in 1916 roa… Quebec City, Quebec central Canada.. Iron from the bridge is both an architectural gem and a national historical site City its. S reply spanning the St. Lawrence bridge Company the other ends pulled off their supports the... Bridge also collapsed while being hoisted into place, it … What caused the Quebec.. Came loose and disappeared into the collapse, construction started on a new bridge, on 10 August.! The main pier wood wedged in tightly at the bottom of the Quebec bridge.. 'S tay bridge Disaster a “ traveller ” Lajeunesse landed he was not the case soon after they to. Published six times a year in English with a single long cantilever span, but I stood there Prime of., stood up, fell down in my box, stood up, fell down again, and on 11! 1917 and the central span also collapsed while being hoisted into place, it … What caused Quebec!

One With Aspirations Crossword Clue, Mind Twisting Movies On Netflix, Crying And Shouting During Pregnancy, How To Get Your Architecture License In California, Compiler Construction Tools, Omertà'' In Inglese,

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *